Thursday, February 14, 2008

The exodus begins? Plus the Edwards endorsement

One of Hillary's superdelegates bolts to Obama.

For some reason surpassing human comprehension, the media keeps playing up John Edwards's possible endorsement. Evidently, he might be leaning toward Clinton, but maybe not. I don't think he's likely to endorse her--he probably just wants to make it seem like a bigger story when he endorses Obama. He's shown a greater proclivity to help Obama in the past, and since I don't think HRC would offer him anything it doesn't really make sense politically.

In a greater sense, however, I find it hard to shake the belief that this endorsement is largely irrelevant. Had Edwards endorsed immediately upon exiting the race, he might (might!) have been able to divert his supporters into either the Clinton camp or the Obama camp. But, for whatever reason, he chose not to do so. It doesn't really make much sense to me unless Edwards is trying to keep his moment in the limelight from ending quite so quickly. Now that Edwards's supporters have migrated to the two remaining candidates, it seems unlikely that Edwards will be able to persuade the ones who went to the one he didn't choose to go to the one he did, especially if he keeps talking about how much he likes them both, how hard a decision it is, etc. Why would an ex-Edwards now-Clinton supporter switch sides because John Edwards says that he prefers Obama but still likes Clinton a lot? It's hardly a persuasive argument.

In essence, Edwards had a chance to impact the race, but he lost it because he wanted desperately to keep his candle burning a little longer. If I had to speculate, I would guess that even though Edwards's moment really has come and gone, he is probably not done running for things. He just likes the attention, and I can see a sort of Senator Moonbat thing happening in the future: he just seems like the sort of personality that would keep running for president with ever-diminishing returns. I could be wrong: who knows? I'm not a huge fan--I think he's a bit annoying, personally, and Wonkette aptly described his voice as a cross between Al Gore and Kermit the Frong. As for the present, his endorsement will have no effect on the race, as both sides have some former Edwards supporters and both sides have some progressive champions. Now, if Al Gore were to endorse someone--well, that would be far more significant. I don't think he will, because he really doesn't have anything to gain from doing it and he has a lot to lose if he picks the wrong pony.

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Vice President Rice

This article on why Condi makes some sense as a GOP VP makes, well, some sense--she adds some starpower, for sure. But the argument for why she'd assuage the religious right is less than laughable--they'd forgive McCain because Rice goes to church? Jimmy Carter is a regular churchgoer, as is Obama, but I would worry that Rice's firm pro-choice stance would actually cause McCain far more grief with religious conservatives, not to mention the amount of traction that Democrats could get out of playing that clip of Condi saying "Bin Laden Determined To Attack Within U.S."

And, ultimately, such a pairing just doesn't make much sense in another way: McCain's wingery on war is not in question. His wingery on social issues very much is. And picking a social liberal isn't going to cut it with that crowd. Sure, putting an ultra-hawk on the ticket might go over well with the "hell yeahs", but it isn't going to be enough. He's going to want to pick a "complete" conservative, and probably someone that the religious right in particular loves. Republicans like Condoleeza Rice, sure, but they probably don't want a pro-choicer a heartbeat away, especially with the elderly McCain in office.

This being said, the Iraq War really is the litmus test for today's GOP, even more than abortion, maybe even more than immigration. Or so we're led to believe. But while Condi on the ticket might have some upsides, it's a pretty risky proposition, and it would be just as likely to antagonize the Christianists as to please them. They might love her as SecState, but that's because they like her foreign policy. There's more to a VP, and less, than just foreign policy.

The McCain Train

This post by Ross got me thinking--why is McCain running a campaign based on the opposite of what the polls say, what common sense says, and what McCain himself has said on any number of issues? I don't think it's impossible for the GOP to win this election, but McCain's frame on the Iraq issue is terrible. By presenting the Iraq War as a choice between a summary withdrawal and staying in there for 10,000 years, he's making the summary withdrawal option much, much more attractive. Hell, even Bush has avoided saying stuff like that, even though he probably feels it. And most people, of course, want to let the Bush tax cuts expire for the wealthy.

Is it that McCain, despite (or perhaps because of) his favorable press coverage every time he voted against a Republican cloture motion, is convinced that being as against the conventional wisdom as possible is a ticket to victory? Has he started to believe the "Maverick" BS? Most people don't care about national honor in the same sense that McCain does--his conquest-oriented honor is more suited to the era of Napoleon than today. Most people don't think a failed invasion will be the end of America. I do suspect that he thinks that, deep down in his gut, most Americans don't want to lose this war. And maybe they would prefer not to. But most just don't care any more because they realize that it never had anything to do with protecting us, and the calculations to get into this war were less than honorable to begin with.

This is why I don't think McCain is a very good politician. He's gotten lots of favorable press, but surely he could come up with a better frame than this, and especially a frame that targets people other than himself? There's a very strange solipsism to John McCain--he seems to think that deep down, most people are like him--which manages the singular feat of being more simplistic than the Bush worldview. He's never really been in a close race for anything, so he lacks that experience. On the other hand, he has a lot of experience with getting beaucoup press for voting against the GOP caucus for kitten immunization or whatever, so he probably thinks that people really want to hear what they don't want to hear. He's made a name off of doing it, after all. Evidently getting beaten in Kansas and Louisiana and very nearly getting beaten in such religious right enclaves as Washington State and Virginia hasn't taught him that not all people like being told how to feel and how to be. McCain is a lecturer. A solipsistic lecturer. Plus a bad campaigner and all the rest. And I'm reasonably sure that he's not going to win this year. But we'll see.

Tuesday, February 12, 2008

Big Pimpin'

I agree with frere Kaus:

Either Chelsea is a political actor or she is not. If she can give speeches on her own and can call superdelegates, she is fair game, period.

I think that this whole dustup was a little silly. I'm not defending this Shuster fellow, but the Clinton campaign can't both put Chelsea out there to campaign and still try to protect her like they did in the 1990s.

Mountains into Mole-Hills

I know Andrew Sullivan is sort of a persona non grata among liberals these days, and not for no reason. And I know that the media's self-serving justification for covering horserace rather than policy is that a candidate's skill at running a campaign is predictive at how they'd perform as president (which is wholly untrue, by the way, as George W. Bush's campaigns were rather masterfully handled!). Still, I find Sullivan's post here to be rather accurate. Clinton's campaign was horribly run from the beginning, but it used to be the case that she had so much goodwill and institutional advantages that it didn't matter. Even if she does manage to pull this out, at least her campaign's weaknesses will be better known and will be improvable.

Does this necessarily mean that she would be a worse president? I'm unsure. I do think that the Obama campaign's success does speak well of his political abilities. But what I'd really be worried about is Hillary getting the nomination and running another terrible general election campaign, like she has in the primary. I'd be worried that, in the event of a win, she wouldn't learn the right lessons. I'd be worried that, despite all her talk about how she knows how to win, she has not exactly exhibited a tremendous amount of skill in that department. To some extent she overpromised things she couldn't deliver, but as I've said, frontrunners don't just give away delegates, even if they don't live in the right zip code. And the less said about Bill's role on the campaign, the better. Paul Krugman might like me to believe that the Jesse Jackson remark might open to multiple interpretations, but here's how it reads to me, "Barack Obama won South Carolina because he's Black. So did Jesse Jackson. And neither one will be elected president because of these facts." If anything, that's a reading that's overly charitable to Bill.

Sunday, February 10, 2008

Obama Derangement Syndrome

Patient Zero: Paul Krugman. His article brings up some good points, but I'm not sure what he's getting at here:
I won’t try for fake evenhandedness here: most of the venom I see is coming from supporters of Mr. Obama, who want their hero or nobody. I’m not the first to point out that the Obama campaign seems dangerously close to becoming a cult of personality. We’ve already had that from the Bush administration — remember Operation Flight Suit? We really don’t want to go there again.
That seems like a pretty venomous comment in and of itself--comparing Barack Obama to George Bush is a pretty low blow, and the connection here is tenuous at best. Does he mean to say that Obama will begin to show George Bush's narcissism because many people love him? Maybe that will happen, but the point is not proven in any way. Not to mention that, in a lot of ways, the Clintons' supporters could be considered a cult of personality as well. And why, exactly, is this comparison made? Because Obama has some fanatical supporters? I'll admit the point. Notice how this is all generalized, though: no specific examples, no statistics, no acknowledgment of some of the also-ravenous anti-Obama voices that have popped up on comment boards on blogs everywhere. At least he's honest about not being evenhanded.

The article does make some good points about the need to not just let unjust anti-Clinton smears stand, but Krugman is evincing a disturbing pattern here. For ages, he criticized Obama for being insufficiently left-wing, or something. Then that National Journal piece said that Obama was the liberal senator. So Krugman continues attacking Obama, but this time he starts using some new Beltway-tailored CW about the "cultlike" Obama campaign. Well, Obama inspires strong emotions in people. It's true. So what? The most charitable reading of his article is that he's worried that some Obama fans might sit out November if Obama is not the nominee, thus depriving Democrats of a victory. This is worrisome, I'll admit. But he cites no statistics or polls to back this up, it's just something he intuits. A more realistic reading is that Krugman has developed an intense, personal aversion to Barack Obama, most likely because the senator offered some muted criticism of Krugman months ago, and since then Krugman has been on the attack. Since he can no longer creditably attack him as insufficiently liberal he's now going to town against the guy on whatever he can find, even if the argument is riddled with generalities and conventional wisdom. I don't mind hearing criticism of Obama if it's correct (I suppose I'm not part of the cult), and I think that Krugman could be in a position to impact the campaign in a positive direction. Krugman, however, doesn't seem to get that he's destroying his reputation by writing these kinds of poorly-supported hit pieces. Let's reverse his hypothetical: what if Obama becomes the nominee? Then right-wingers will be able to quote "left-wing New York Times Columnist Paul Krugman" on how they're right to say that Obama's support is cultlike. He doesn't get it--he's committing the very sin he's condemning. Do as I say, eh...

Ultimately, I'm not sure this is even a good faith argument from Krugman--didn't Dean supporters say that they would bolt the party if Dean didn't get the nomination in 2004? And didn't they wind up being drawn back into the fold in the end? This is getting a little tiresome. If you don't want to be an Obama fan, that's fine. All I'm asking is that he adheres to his (usually) high standards.

The inevitable candidate, ladies and gentlemen...

Hillary Clinton's odds of winning the nomination: 3 in 10, according to Intrade.

Hillary is now pursuing the Giuliani Strategy, v. 2.0, and betting it all on Texas, Pennsylvania and Ohio. She has just lost Maine. She isn't favored to win a primary or caucus for a month. Not only that, but her team is bragging about how little effort they put into these states that Obama recently won. I guess that's the only way they can go, but it doesn't exactly inspire confidence, now, does it?

As Obama wins more and more "blue" states, the meme that Hillary gets the vote of "blue state" Democrats loses coherence for her supporters. Illinois, Delaware, Connecticut, Washington, and now Maine--soon, Maryland, Virginia and D.C., and then Hawaii and Wisconsin. This thing is for real.

For the candidate that has doubled down on "experience" this isn't exactly confidence-inspiring. She doesn't seem to have a clue on how to go up against Obama in these contests--indeed, she seems to still be a step behind Obama instead of the other way around. Did she never even envision the possibility of the campaign going beyond Super Tuesday? Rookie mistake, that. At least her red-faced, finger-wagging husband is keeping out of things now.

Hillary lost her shot to knock Obama out of the race. Nobody is going to save her if she has a lower amount of pledged delegates at the end of primary season, and if she thinks she can snatch this thing with superdelegates she's crazy. At least half the Democratic Party would sit home on election night. The election is over. She lost.

Saturday, February 9, 2008

Super Saturday! Thoughts

Andrew Sullivan:
Two words come to mind when assessing Clinton's apparent strategy to wait the primaries out till bigger, more fertile states: Rudy. Giuliani.
Indeed. I made the same exact comparison in my preceding post. But Sullivan's wrong: if this is Clinton's strategy, it's actually way, way stupider than Rudy's strategy. Rudy's strategy presupposed that Romney, Huckabee, McCain, Thompson, and Paul would all be fighting each other for delegates and that none would have a clear advantage going into Florida. And it wasn't just that the central premise of his strategy failed him--McCain did emerge as a plausible choice--but even if a frontrunner had not emerged, there was really no reason to expect Giuliani to be able to win the states he wanted to. Not getting news cycles for a long time just makes it seem like you're out of the race.

But Hillary isn't the frontrunner facing off against a half-dozen or so also-rans. She's facing one person who has had some incredible momentum in the past few weeks (and she isn't even the frontrunner, according to recent polls). Intrade now gives her about a 38% chance of winning the nomination. Now, she's literally giving away delegates. In other words, she doesn't seem like a candidate going full steam ahead on the way to victory in November--she seems like a candidate that has resigned herself to being beaten. She's going to make a good show of it, and she might win a primary or two along the way--West Virginia, perhaps Oregon, maybe Texas--before bowing out in June after Obama's lead in pledged delegates (and maybe even superdelegates, by that point) forces her to leave. But anything can happen, and in this race, it frequently has.

***

By the way, what in God's name is going on with the Republicans? It seems that they've not gotten the memo about John McCain being the nominee, and so far Kansas and Louisiana have both gone for Mike Huckabee, and Washington State is still very close. If McCain were to be swept five days after seemingly clinching the nomination--if he still cannot win anything in the South--he's in a spot of trouble. I just wonder what Huck's game is. He's not bleeding off votes from Romney any more. Is he trying to prove himself further to McCain for the VP slot? Maybe he's trying to get enough delegates to force McCain to give him the VP spot because he doesn't trust McCain to do it on his own, which is rather devious and potentially dangerous if he doesn't succeed. Or maybe Huckabee's just crazy? That cannot be discounted.

Here's what I think: if Huck really wants to be McCain's running mate, he'll drop out after the next major McCain victory. He can't very well do it tomorrow, not after winning, and theoretically he's got momentum from tonight. But after McCain's next big victory, he could pack it in without much controversy. So wait for McCain's next big night--presumably before he locks down the nomination for good, as then it would be too late for his dropping out to have any effect. As the movie says, "When the fall's all that's left, it matters." I have to believe that Huckabee realizes he's done and just wants to exit gracefully. Then again, if he gets a positive round of press coverage after this, and if he manages to get a nontrivial bump in the polls...maybe he'll start to believe he can become President. And he can't, but if he can win a couple of big winner-take-all primaries along the way, he can make life pretty miserable for McCain's campaign. Which is good news for Democrats. And maybe for Huckabee as well, if he wants to run for President again in 2012...

Yes Obama Can!

These guys still think Hillary Clinton's going to win the nomination, and they might be right. I'm not entirely convinced. To their credit, they both see it being a very narrow victory, which is possible. Hillary had her chance to knock Obama out of the race on Super Tuesday, and she couldn't. The race will never have conditions as favorable to her as it did on Super Tuesday. I just don't see another game-changing moment coming for Hillary--she's thrown everything she could at Obama, from Rezko to drug use, and he's only gotten stronger.

Matt's thesis seems to be that a press backlash against Obama, coupled with an odd Clinton win before the Ohio and Texas primaries, will ensure that she wins those and thus gets the nomination. I think a couple of assumptions are made here that aren't really warranted. Sure, we've seen some scattered articles on how the press is afraid of Obama's "messianistic" fan club, but that isn't necessarily a sign that the press is going to start treating him like Mitt Romney. This kind of thinking reminds me of how some pundits used to wonder aloud about whether the press would turn on John McCain after a single critical article of the man. Anything's possible, but John McCain is the token conservative that the media loves. And they might well decide to turn on Obama, but I'm not sure there's enough data at this point to support that thesis.

In any event, Clinton might win Texas, but I think Obama will in Ohio. He's done very well in the Midwest so far, and he'll have plenty of time to soften up the ground for a little retail politics. Texas will present a much greater challenge, admittedly, and it will be a test of Latino outreach. If he can win there, he wins it all, I think. I'm not sure that a single win will turn the whole game around, though--if Obama manages to put a bunch of victories together this month--say sweeping the contests this weekend, then the DC-area contests on Tuesday, then Wisconsin and Hawaii the week after--will Hillary start to recede into the background? As we saw with Rudy Giuliani's campaign, without the odd victory here and there, it's very difficult to get people to remember your name.

Matt is right to say that Hillary Clinton still does have a committed and large fanbase. However, at this point, it does not seem that they make up the bulk of the Democratic Party, as Obama has led in a couple of the new national polls. And I think Kevin's caveat is pretty likely to come to pass: if it eventually becomes clear that Obama will come out of the primaries with a victory with pledged delegates, you will probably begin to see a lot of pressure from party leaders for Hillary to exit for the sake of party unity. Whether she cares about party unity is an open question, but there will be defections if she doesn't drop out in this circumstance, which I do believe is likely to come to pass. And while the Clintons seem to be talented at trench warfare, as Kevin asserts, hasn't Obama shown some chops there as well? He excels at the back-and-forth and retail politics. Clinton does better with wholesale. And her base actually seems to be shrinking--she doesn't even hold her own against Obama with White folks anymore--it's basically just White women and Latinos at this point. Now, what she's got there is pretty damn near impregnable, but I'd say Obama has got some talents for this sort of game.

I still think Barack can win, and I think he can beat John McCain. Some Democrats might bemoan John McCain winning the nomination, but I don't. McCain is in a unique position in which he can stand up for the Bush worldview in its entirety while still claiming to be a war critic. He can pull off both continuity and change messages, in other words. Putting Hillary against McCain isn't going to work because of this--the two aren't as far apart on foreign policy as one might think, at least as far as their worldview seems to be concerned. A tie goes to the beloved straight-talker, in my estimation. Obama, on the other hand, has shown the willingness and the ability to engage that worldview and propose something different. Plus, the polls say he's more electable. So, it just makes sense to pick him. And as for those people who are worried about his political skills, let's not forget that if he pulls this off, he will have won the Democratic nomination for President by defeating Hillary Clinton! She had more advantages than most non-incumbents could ever have. I'd say he's got the acumen, and Hillary Clinton is actually pretty good on the attack, whereas one needs only recall McCain's Janet Reno joke to see what he's capable of in that department. John McCain is actually a very overrated politician--he is a terrible speaker, foot-in-mouth disease, so-so debater, messy personal history, not to mention his age, temper, and health.

Thursday, February 7, 2008

It occurs to me that when it comes to nominations, as in many things, the Democrats have got it figured out much more than the GOP. It occurred to me that, as the GOP largely loathes McCain, his victory would have been far less assured had they generally used a proportional awarding of delegates rather than a winner-take-all system for primary elections. McCain wouldn't have nearly the delegates he has now if they had been awarded in a proportional system--it seems bizarre that he's got nearly 80% of the delegates he needs despite breaking 50% in only a very few states. Now, the GOP is stuck with a nominee that many of its members cannot stand.

On a fundamental level, this sort of thing just seems silly to me. Why should a person win all of, say, Texas's electoral votes if, for example, they only squeaked by with a 38-36 victory? With the Democrats, it's all about the ground game, all about how well you do everywhere, and winning 80% is better than 60%, which is better than winning with 38% in a crowded field. How you win matters.

The Man, The Myth, The Bio

East Bay, California, United States
Problem: I have lots of opinions on politics and culture that I need to vent. If I do not do this I will wind up muttering to myself, and that's only like one or two steps away from being a hobo. Solution: I write two blogs. A political blog that has some evident sympathies (pro-Obama, mostly liberal though I dissent on some issues, like guns and trade) and a culture blog that does, well, cultural essays in a more long-form manner. My particular thing is taking overrated things (movies, mostly, but other things too) down a peg and putting underrated things up a peg. I'm sort of the court of last resort, and I tend to focus on more obscure cultural phenomena.