Thursday, October 2, 2008

A matter of temperament

National Review has a provocative article (via TPM) on temperament and the presidency. It's not a bad argument, actually, and it lands a few decent points, even though it's not very insightful as it's basically the same "Obama's too cool and too disconnected" pablum we've heard for ages, despite every poll showing voters feel Obama connects more with them than McCain, shares their values, etc.

But it also makes the case that McCain's temperament is better suited to the presidency, which is an interesting one. I don't dispute its assumptions, or even its arguments to a degree, but I do dispute its conclusions. McCain's temperament manifests itself in flying off the handle whenever something goes wrong. It leads to brash and unnecessary consequences that just make the overall situation worse. See: Sarah Palin. While a "fighter" (more specifically, in FDR's parlance, a "happy warrior") is something the American people want in a leader, McCain doesn't come across a happy anything, and rather than harnessing his anger he allows it to diffuse indifferently. He presents the appearance of a man who is not entirely in control of his emotions, which is most assuredly not a good thing. And I'm not sure in what universe the authors of this piece are living when they tick off this list of positive attributes about McCain:

zeal, decisiveness, perseverance, a certainty of opinion on fundamental matters of right and wrong and on our core national values

I'll give you zeal, and I'll give you the certainty, but perseverance from a guy who has changed his positions so many times? Decisiveness from a man who keeps sinking time and resources into states he can't win, like Iowa. And I, like most Americans, believe Obama better embodies our core values than McCain. But then again, I like a man who is confident and self-assured enough not to throw a tantrum every time something bad happens. But I'm a Bay Area Liberal, so what do I know?

Robert Gates should stay on as Defense Secretary

Mindful of the complaints of folks like Matt Yglesias, who question the symbolism of a Republican SecDef in a Democratic administration as a tacit admission that Democrats can't really keep them safe, I think that Obama should offer Bob Gates an extension in the job. It would be a real act of bipartisanship, and it's meritocratic, as Gates has done a fine job in the role. He's been honest and effective, and he's killed a few wasteful projects here and there. I doubt Gates would stick around for more than a year or two, anyway, as he's intent on retiring, at which point Obama could put in Wes Clark or Jim Webb or someone like that. The symbolism does suck, but these are extenuating circumstances, as Gates has done a damn good job.

Plus, in case the GOP has a "stabbed in the back" narrative in waiting with respect to Iraq, Gates being in charge helps defuse it. When it comes to cabinet appointments, the other GOPer that should be considered is Chuck Hagel for Secretary of State. He knows his stuff and he's a rare non-neocon Republican. I don't see an Yglesian case for why this would be bad for Democrats, as Democrats are naturally considered more inclined toward diplomacy than are Republicans these days. Picking someone who agrees with you with respect to the job at hand but disagrees with you on most other things simply looks good, and I doubt it erodes Obama's reputation as being a proponent of tough diplomacy much at all.

On the other hand, I don't think putting Republicans at Treasury, Justice or Homeland Security makes much sense. The latter is really bad if you also have a Republican at defense, and putting a Democrat at justice is necessary due to all the partisan firings and manipulation there, just to balance things out. Chris Dodd would be my choice there (though I doubt it will be him), and I think that Sam Nunn is a good choice for Secretary of Homeland Security. I honestly have no idea who would be a good treasury secretary. Jon Corzine? Who knows what sort of ethics things are going on with him. Robert Reich, perhaps?

Landslide alert

McCain gives up on Michigan. Michigan is a perpetual swing state. Where else can he play? Wisconsin (where some of those folks are moving) doesn't look much closer according to 538, New Hampshire is looking irrelevant these days, and Pennsylvania is even more hopeless than Michigan. McCain is mostly moving staff to Ohio and Florida. So, basically, he's playing defense, and he's pretty much admitting he isn't going to win any Kerry or Gore states, as Michigan was his best chance (New Hampshire, inexplicably, looks still within reach).

Think about it: Obama will win all the Gore states without much in the way of opposition. All he's got to do is win Florida or North Carolina or Ohio or Colorado and New Hampshire, all states where he currently leads. Or he can win states where he's effectively tied, like Missouri or Indiana. McCain has to win every single one to win.

It's hard to overstate the importance of this. For much of this cycle, Michigan looked like McCain's best pickup opportunity. Now it's off the table. Obama will win there by double digits.

Controlling expectations

While a number of lefty bloggers (myself included) are predicting that Palin will win tonight by exceeding expectations, Mike Tomasky has a different impression:

The media have been saying things like, "as long as she doesn't seem like a total idiot, she'll win." But I don't think that's right. I actually believe that substance matters in these forums a little more than that. One of the reasons Barack Obama beat John McCain in their first debate is that many viewers found him more substantive than they'd figured him to be. Whether they can remember specific things he said isn't the point. It's that he came across as knowledgeable.

So put it this way if you like: command of substance is a form of performance. A candidate could not get up there and, however charismatically and empathically, read from the St. Louis telephone directory. You have to know something.


The bulk of the voters that have come to disapprove of Palin over the past few weeks have been women. Disproportionately so. Women who, quite probably, feel insulted by the Palin pick. Women who sense that she's not ready and that she's the quintissential airhead hottie that represents one of the two major sexist memes against women--the other being the castrating bitch, something that the GOP has invested much time in painting Clinton as the exemplar. Giving a muddled, evasive performance tonight--which has got to be the best that she can offer--isn't really going to dissuade these women. They probably think (as do I) that Palin is going to set back their ability to be taken seriously, as she is a living embodiment of one of the prevalent sexist memes. The woman knows nothing. What's amazing is that that makes the GOP only love her more. That bespeaks volumes as to how debased that party has become.

I tend to think Tomasky is right here, for the simple reason that pundits don't set expectations: the American people do. And while a few Palin likers might come back to her if she has a not-so-bad performance, I simply don't think it will be enough to reverse the tidal waves of the campaign. In the end, I'm not much up on the media these days, because it seems to be an institution of rich elites whose primary goal these days is to try to get into the heads of ordinary folks to predict horserace nonsense. God forbid they actually try to educate the public on issues!

Klein: Obama's temperament superior!

Joe Klein contrasts the temperaments of the two candidates. His conclusion: Obama has shown steely resolve, and McCain is hotheaded and impulsive. Surprise! Still, his article here is well worth reading.

One of the most bizarre things about this cycle has been the meltdown of John McCain's relations with the press (e.g. Klein), which he used to call his base. But maintaining relationships with people who are, definitionally, high information types was incompatible with running the Rove-on-steroids plan that Steve Schmidt cooked up--a plan that created a campaign predicated on deceit: McCain will, for example, deny he's said things on the public record; he will talk out of both sides of his mouth; and he will do whatever he can to distract the public from the issues or his running mate's obvious inadequacies. Plus, there are all the flip flops. Informed people scoffed at all this, but McCain shrugged it off, saying that Obama rejected his town hall debates offer and then actually claimed that the media was biased against McCain himself! An incredible statement, considering that the media was largely responsible for his prestige and popularity, that he received more favorable press coverage than any other politician, that they still took him seriously after his campaign imploded as a result of immigration and they were largely responsible for McCain's being able to win New Hampshire, which turned his campaign around.

One wonders if the Obama campaign could use this to its advantage: that high-profile media elites who follow this stuff for a living have been turning their backs on McCain. That message might not exactly resonate with Middle America--poor fussy elites, right?--but the fact still remains that one of McCain's core groups of support has largely turned against him (Tom Brokaw excepted), and that McCain's reaction to this wasn't to take stock of this pretty significant development but rather to play the predictable "the press hates me" card that conservatives always play. And McCain, win or lose, will never have those relationships again. He's destroyed his reputation for nothing. Congrats, Senator Dumbass.

Just desserts

To borrow a phrase from Malcolm (or Jeremiah Wright, if you prefer), McCain's chickens are coming home to roost. So much the better. I always find satisfaction in someone losing money (so to speak) by betting on the stupidity of the American public.

Palin is responsible for McCain's decline

Here. I have to say that Andrew's been saying that picking Palin was McCain's fatal mistake for ages now, and recent events have only vindicated him. What makes me wonder is this debate tonight. In one respect, cancelling Palin's debate might have been beneficial for Obama, since the public doesn't seem to care much for Palin anymore, and absent a major public event to redeem herself the course might never have been righted. So, she'll probably regain a little bit at the polls as a result of this debate, but probably not that much and not for long, because if she performs well, folks like Bill Kristol and Mitt Romney who have been pushing the whole "let Palin be Palin" meme will feel vindicated and demand more public appearances for Palin. And that's a surefire way to disaster.

At the end of the day, though, I trust the public to see through this, as they've seen through a lot of the malarkey this cycle. But I suspect that even if Palin manages a command performance she's not the only one on her ticket suffering profound problems of popularity.

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

What Ifill should do

So, the right has decided that Gwen Ifill is obviously biased and can't be trusted to moderate the debate. They decide this now. Not back when the moderators were picked for these debates. Not in 2004, when she moderated the VP debate. Now. Right before Sarah Palin undergoes this debate. I really hope that she junks the rules for the debates and aggressively follows up questions about the economy and such, as well as throwing a couple of curveballs. I'd be interested to see what Sarah Palin's views on net neutrality are, for example (just kidding, if she hasn't heard of Time Magazine she's probably not heard of the internet either). Now, obviously, such things could be biased if they are geared to, say, foreign policy arcana that a president could learn on the fly (and that Biden would know), since it's not necessary (nor possible) that a president know everything. But I think that Ifill ought to throw some curveballs in there.

Here's the thing: they don't even really have to be policy curveballs. Maybe ask her something like what her biggest mistake was and what she learned from it. Maybe ask her what she thought of the Sopranos finale. Maybe ask her what her favorite vice president was. This is a woman that, by all indications, has no clue. Force her into some spontaneity and she'll crumble, just like she has in the past.

McCain campaign's incompetence

I found this post by a GOP strategist amusing. What is McCain doing in Iowa, a state that Obama will likely win by double digits? Why not in Virginia, which has shown an Obama lead as of late? Plus, it's closer to Washington, so you have a shorter plane ride to the vote. Or how about North Carolina and Indiana, two previously dark-red states where FiveThirtyEight shows Obama pretty much tied? Why the incompetence? Is Sarah Palin running this outfit now?

Maybe it's because McCain's campaign knows only how to win news cycles, and can't develop a coherent electoral strategy.

Palin not the new Clinton

Good piece on the pitfalls of dealing with Palin. I think it is accurate to say that she is a perfect embodiment of the right side of the culture war, and "anti-intellectual evangelical reactionary" is just as good a description of her as any. Still, I don't think there's quite as neat a symmetry between Palin and Bill Clinton in terms of the culture war. I don't think that Bill Clinton was really the embodiment of the left side of the culture war. I think he was the embodiment of the baby boomer generation, but I think there's a distinction to make here. Palin is hated by left-side culture warriors because of her image and what she stands for, and similarly beloved by the right-side culture warriors for the same reason. Clinton was hated by the right because of what he stood for, but he was not really embraced by the left--partially because of his policies, but also partially because he failed to live up to his initial promise as the next JFK, who I'd say still is the ideal of the modern day left culture.

Clinton largely survived because he made the correct enemies that a left-leaning politician would make, and the thought of, say, Newt Gingrich winning the shutdown crisis or the impeachment crisis was simply unpalatable to lefties. But Clinton never gave the left more than lip service, and the left accordingly never repaid him with much enthusiasm, though they did remain loyal to him. Palin's position is relatively stronger, as the GOP base is solidly behind her. Unfortunately, Palin isn't blessed with Clinton's reputation for competence and his knowledge of policy, not to mention his persuasive capacity. She can, of course, use her sportscaster training to deliver a good zinger or two, but it's not going to be enough in a country that has tired of anti-intellectual hillbillies. Just an opinion.

The Man, The Myth, The Bio

East Bay, California, United States
Problem: I have lots of opinions on politics and culture that I need to vent. If I do not do this I will wind up muttering to myself, and that's only like one or two steps away from being a hobo. Solution: I write two blogs. A political blog that has some evident sympathies (pro-Obama, mostly liberal though I dissent on some issues, like guns and trade) and a culture blog that does, well, cultural essays in a more long-form manner. My particular thing is taking overrated things (movies, mostly, but other things too) down a peg and putting underrated things up a peg. I'm sort of the court of last resort, and I tend to focus on more obscure cultural phenomena.