Thursday, May 14, 2009

Why on Earth would you defend Jack Murtha?

I realize he's Nancy Pelosi's BFF and that he played a big role in the public's turnaround, but really? Really? Look, there's every reason to think that Murtha's corrupt, and he's exactly the sort of corrupt porker that Democrats should be making an example of by not protecting him. I doubt they'd lose much by dumping the dude. One wonders if this isn't Pelosi playing defense by trying to keep her biggest friends in powerful places, but it only adds to the stink already on her from the revelation that she might well have known about waterboarding all along. (Though I tend to believe the rumors are correct, I am not passing judgment at this time.)

I tend to like Pelosi and I think she's been a good leader for the Democrats, very underrated in fact. But I think she's already a compromised figure, and she's getting more compromised by the day. At this point she should be trying to minimize the cloud of suspicion around her, not maximize it. Something tells me that, unless she has a brilliant plan to get out of these messes, she won't be gaveling in the 112th Congress.

Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Filibuster reform

This Dawn Johnsen business is appalling, and it seems rather tactically unsound to me. Filibustering everything in sight is only going to make reform a more attractive option for the majority, and using it in such a partisan manner is going to ensure that even Blue Dogs will eventually be forced to turn against it. It's a dumb move, but Mitch McConnell is hardly one of the best political minds of his generation. Let Obama get the team he wants, barring real improprieties, I say.

I don't mind preserving the idea of the filibuster, but it can't work as it is working. It seems to me that the best path toward reform is to put a clock on filibusters--sort of like a suspensive veto. If a large enough minority of senators objects to a bill or nominee, they can filibuster it for a while--let's say three months. During that time, they can try to persuade other legislators, influence public opinion, or work toward a compromise. Three months later, if a majority of senators still supports the bill, they get to vote on it and it becomes law.

I'd be willing to tinker with the time limit, but I do think that some sort of bypass like this needs to take place. The status quo isn't particularly fair or democratic, and the reason it is the status quo is because the Senate dons--McConnell and Cornyn--are interested only in their own power and prerogatives. But I think they've overplayed their hand, and something is going to have to give, if not now, then later.

My take on education reform

There's a great discussion about education reform going on over at The League, among other places. Here's E.D. Kain:
Teachers make a huge difference. I think it’s important to pay them well, and to give them an incentive to stick around. It’s also important to treat them like professionals; to properly accredit them (but also to make that process easier for professionals in other fields); and to give them options that make their teaching careers better on the whole. So teacher choice, I’d say, ranks right up there with school choice in terms of things we should be thinking about in the education debates. Michelle Rhee seems to be on to something with her “green vs red” tracks. We’ll see how it plays out.
The more I read about education reform, the more complicated it seems. I don't tend to think that teacher's unions are the only or even the major problem in education today, as states with excellent education have teacher's unions, just like states with poor education do. I am also wary about using purely statistical measures to measure education, as they smack of a statistical obsession that feels too corporate to me, and as The Wire shows, they can be juked to create the illusion of progress so as to take pressure off of responsible parties. My suspicion is that a lot of what's wrong with education isn't necessarily about the bureaucracy (though heaven knows there's much that's wrong there) so much as that a lot of the public simply doesn't see much value in education, either because they don't feel they can succeed or because it's seen as irrelevant to what people are dealing with, or both. Education can be the way toward class mobility and economic opportunity, but an awful lot of things have to go right in order for a poor rural white kid (or a poor urban black kid) to make it. And, on some level, the kids that do make it have to be self-confident enough to leave their communities behind--as Spike Lee memorably stated, trying to move out of the lower class is like a crab trying to get out of a bottle of crabs--they keep pulling you back in. So I tend to say that incremental reforms, like what E.D. is saying here, make sense to me. I'm not completely opposed to school choice, though I tend to be more supportive of charter schools than spending money on unaccountable private/religious schools. I'm a little skeptical about the merits of "competition" here, because I think that the relevant metrics are deeply flawed, and I don't know if the end result is more achievable with public schools bleeding money and their best students because I suspect that an easy path to reform would long since have been implemented. Clearly I have more reading to do on the subject.

I do think that this is a very smart idea:

Kids not academically inclined should have available to them apprenticeship-like programs designed to teach them useful trades. I think this could have a profound effect on graduation rates.

I know that Germany does something similar to this. I think it's a good idea, and I sometimes take a beating for it from other liberals who are of the "everyone should go to college" mindset. That is just silly. I think everyone should be able to go to college if they want to and have the qualifications. But many have neither, so I generally don't think that "universal college" is a good idea. Some people just aren't built for that, and that shouldn't mean exile to a life of burger-flipping that is the life of not having a GED. There's nothing wrong with being a plumber in my book, and from what I hear the pay is pretty good. It's probably more exciting than any number of college-educated positions. Liberalism gets a bad name primarily because there is often an all-knowing sort of chauvinism at play, one which tends to treat women who choose to stay at home to raise kids as tantamount to sellouts, or that automatically assumes that pregnant teens ought to have abortions as a matter of course. I get the sense that education is part of this general tendency, that letting some students choose a career-oriented track instead of a purely academic one (I'm sure they'd still take some history classes!) is somehow consigning them to a life of vile servitude at the hands of The Man. But it's not. What liberalism is and must be is a way of maximizing the liberty of individuals to make the choices that are right for them. We educate, they decide. What choices they make ought not to concern us at all.

Into the world of gay Republicans

Jamie Kirchick files a must-read article here.

The slippery slope, revisited

“I think you can see the kind of slippery slope we’re going down here,” he said. “What I see here is individuals trying to change the definition of a longstanding institution called marriage to fit into their agenda.” -- New York Assemblyman James Tedisco

You know it's not a good sign when a person uses the words "slippery slope" in a public argument and thinks that that makes his point more compelling.

Merely because something can happen doesn't mean that it will happen. Support for gay marriage is not a predictor for future support for polygamy. Indeed, I support the former and oppose the latter because one is about advancing equality while the other is about demeaning it. Allowing a man to marry multiple women demeans the women--they become another status symbol, another thing to acquire. This doesn't mention the inconvenient fact that few women in this country are particularly interested in being part of a brood of wives.

What one sees, over and over again, out of gay marriage opponents is a fear of change, pure and simple. It is, among many, a very acute fear and a sympathetic one. But that is all it is. And that is what this quote suggests: a fear that their model of society is being rejected. In reality, allowing gays and lesbians to be married will have at best a marginal effect--the other 97% of new marriages will follow the one man, one woman model. This isn't a redefinition so much as a small change to the admission criteria.

Why are Republicans playing into the Democrats' hands?

Yglesias again, this time about Rush Limbaugh:
Rush’s defenders understand, I hope, that painting Rush as the all-powerful lord of conservatism before whom all else must submit was, in its origins, a political strategy devised by their enemies, right? So why are they jumping so quickly to prove that the argument is dead-on?

I think they're doing it because they can't help doing it, and that's because the strategy of using Rush as the voice of conservatism was a surprisingly shrewd one. Rush clearly wants the job, and influential conservatives are either afraid of him or agree with him, even if they find him at least somewhat offensive. And it's definitely true that there's nobody within the GOP with enough political capital to fight a war with Rush.

Portraying Rush as the face of conservatism was a strategy predicated on using the conservative movement's defining characteristics--ingroup loyalty--against the GOP. The strategy is simple: attack one of the totemic (and anathemic) media loudmouths of the Republican Party and force the GOP to either defend him, which makes him more prominent and hurts the GOP, or to denounce him, which alienates his 17 million or however many viewers. It's a no-win scenario, but you can't lose if you don't play, as The Wire tells us. But the conservative movement isn't headed by shrewd, savvy politicians--it's headed by wingnut bloggers who can't wisely avoid taking the bait and have a wee bit of a tendency to overreact to things. Hence, the GOP walking right into the Obama team's trap on Rush.

What this really shows is that the GOP is incredibly easy to manipulate. All you have to do is make a few stray remarks about Rush Limbaugh and the "Party of No" to make the entire Republican base go apeshit, to the point where Sean Hannity spends an entire segment on the president's mustard choice and the RNC will only refer to the party in power as the "Democrat Socialist Party". These people don't seem to get that Obama is a formidable opponent who has a tendency to turn his opponents into complete drooling idiots. I'd say that Obama's goal of marginalizing the Republicans is going pretty well--he's showing some traces of Nixonian shrewdness at this point (mostly in a good way).

Flattery and the media

Matt Yglesias says:
Some 30-40 years ago, the mainstream media came under sustained attack from the conservative movement. The critique was that, basically, the press should compromise its mission of doing its best to tell the truth and instead give equal rate to the truth and to whatever the conservative movement wanted to convince people of on any given day. Virtually every institution decided that the best way to cope was to slowly but surely give in to that pressure.

Meanwhile, technological change has undermined the financial viability of a lot of these institutions. And now they’re feeling sorry for themselves. But the very same changes open up possibilities for new institutions—institutions that are not as compromised by decades-worth of burning their own credibility—to do amazing work. On balance, I’m excited about the new era.
I think this explains a lot, and I tend to agree. I'm not of the opinion that the media should stick its nose in and declare a victor for every issue--a lot of social issues and economic issues have more than one valid answer, and it's better to report what both sides have to say and let people decide. Obviously, when one side is lying the obligation is to call them out on it, and the media has proven to be almost pathologically incapable of doing this, to the extent of peddling silly trash about Barack Obama's pastor as though it were a revelation (and few people cared), or devising tons of false equivalencies (remember the Social Security debate?) to avoid ever having to make strong statements about anything.

I think that, on balance, this has not only destroyed the reputation of the national press corps, but it's also played a not-insignificant role in the eventual derangement of the Republican Party. The media did not take a skeptical tone on laissez-faire and supply-siderism, which led, respectively, to a financial collapse and enormous deficits. The media didn't deign to criticize Bush's utopianism democracy promotion, which led invariably to a decline of American power and unnecessary wars. Hell, even the Afghanistan War ought to have been questioned--we might well have had causus belli, but was it absolutely necessary to our security to invade and hold another country, rather than just making surgical strikes on al-Qaeda? I guess we'll never know. But had the media stood up and asked tough questions of a conservative president some of these disasters might well have been averted--indefensible positions might well have been knocked down. This is, of course, the point of having a media--to ask the difficult questions, to be skeptical, not to just defer to elected officials and wax indignant when they lie to you. It is ironic that the media did wind up killing the GOP in the end, as they always figured it would--but it killed them with kindness.

I suspect that this is behind why torture opponents haven't won the torture debate--the GOP has turned it into a partisan issue, and Washington elites are therefore not going to even challenge that view. It would be biased. What if the GOP supported a law to make everyone wear polka-dot shirts on Fridays? Would this get a respectful hearing? It sounds silly, but if the heavy-hitters were out there on Sunday morning talk shows, doing a full-on blitz, I honestly doubt that the press corps would mock them. (Read Ta-Nehisi for more on the torture stuff--I do think the lack of concern over this boils down partly to a lack of empathy but not so much about national innocence, as Bush ruined that with Iraq. I suspect it's still lingering fear of another 9/11, and let's be honest here--many Americans are just as utopian as Bush was about removing evil from the world, and fundamentally lack courage, physical and otherwise. But I'm done.)

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Rove on Torture

This is too good not to share (hat tip to Kevin Drum):
It has served, frankly, I think, as a recruiting tool. They can now take these memoranda and go to prospective, you know, recruits and say, This is the worst that the enemy, the United States, would ever do to you....It’s given them a tool to make it more attractive to recruit people, and you know, this kind of thing is harmful to us over the long haul.
I realize that Rove's whole thing is projection, and this is certainly an exercise in that, but I see this as evidence of a bigger problem--the right's tendency to overincentivize human activity. I'm not saying that people don't respond to incentives or that we shouldn't offer them in order to encourage people to do laudatory things. But just look at the gaping void known as the GOP's social policy to get a sense of how much the CEO mindset has seized the Republican Party. How else to interpret hostility toward allowing gays to serve in the armed forces or ensuring nondiscrimination in securing a home loan or getting a job aside from as a function of a worldview that says that making things tough enough on gay folks will turn them straight? That allowing gay folks even fundamental rights in our society is somehow "emboldening" the gay community. And then there's foreign policy--we can't do this, because it will embolden the enemy. We can't do that, because it will show weakness. In other words, because it will incentivize attacking or not.

As I said, this sort of calculus has its place. But when it comes to foreign policy what's more important than incentives are interests. The Middle East is, largely, poor (with some clusters of rich oil magnates), lacking in infastructre and economy, and as usually happens in countries that can't sustain themselves the ruling elites who caused the problems cast about for scapegoats. America and Israel make good ones--we're foreign, speak different languages then they do, there's ancient and modern hostility there and there's the little matter of the Palestinian crisis and the Iraq War to help sell us as bad guys. But nobody in Iran, for example, is hungry because of us. Nobody in Saudi Arabia is unemployed because of us. Admittedly, our alliance with Israel makes us partly responsible for the Palestinian crisis, and we need to try to find a fair solution to that problem. But we're not really keeping the Arab world down, and most Arabs know it. However, this sort of vicious cycle can generate free-floating anger that demagogues can deploy against their enemies. And an enemy that engages in torture is even easier to demagogue against (as the late Saddam Hussein could attest to, were he still alive). Not torturing makes their case a little harder (though they manage nicely), but it also keeps moderate Muslims from radicalizing. Perhaps that's too strong a claim: I'll just say that torturing certainly led to moderate Muslims being radicalized, according to sources too numerous to name. (Jane Mayer is one.)

But this bit from Rove is really mystifying. Terrorists who are ready to kill themselves are going to be cowed by the threat of torture? Sounds a lot like the notion that tougher jail sentences will be a deterrent to drug dealers. People who aren't afraid of dying for their cause aren't going to respond to incentives like this, and incentives matter less when matters of real conviction are involved. (I'm a detractor of the rational economic actor model, but that is a discussion for a later time.) This is vintage Rove, trying to turn an opponent's strength into a weakness, only it's so incoherent that one wonders whether Rove's heart is still in it. And the GOP's revolving door of failures spins round once again.

Oh, yeah, and have I mentioned that I'm really glad that Republican Senator Bob Corker of Tennessee beat Harold Ford in 2006? Here's why.

Crist is in

He's running for the Senate. I must confess that Charlie Crist is one of my favorite Republicans, and might well be a plausible path toward Republican revival in 2016 or later. He has exactly the sort of profile that might be attractive for a GOP desperate to appeal to young voters: he has a strong environmental record, comparatively good on health care, moderate on gay rights, and generally more willing to accept compromise and work in a bipartisan manner, instead of the Boehner-McConnell scorched earth model that is only making the GOP more unpopular. He's not dogmatic (though he is assuredly conservative, especially on tax issues--see Nate Silver for more). He seems like almost exactly the politician that Republicans ought to start noticing.

What's really remarkable is that Crist is an honest, ethical, right-thinking Republican in a party where such traits are much more of a liability than an asset. His support of the stimulus, is spurning of ACORN-bashing during the election, his quashing of voter suppression efforts in Florida and his support of allowing released convicts to vote--a no-brainer, in my opinion--are all principled stances of conviction that generally brought him little benefit and might actually have cost him political capital among his base and GOP elites. It's always rare to encounter real conviction politicians, and coming off of a several-year period in which the GOP deservedly got a reputation as a craven and cynical political machine that was more interested in helping its buddies than helping the American people, turning the party over to someone who is in many respects the anti-Rove might be just the ticket. Plus, speaking electorally, being overwhelmingly popular in a critical swing state that was just won by Barack Obama might well be the most valuable asset Crist possesses.

I can tell you right now that a Crist-like (hmm...that just looks wrong) Republican Party would both excite and scare me--it would scare me because Crist could probably win blue states like Oregon and New Hampshire, but it would excite me because Crist could well be the GOP's Tony Blair, reforming his party to compete in modern times while preserving the things worth preserving. And having a principled, intelligent Republican Party is good for the country. Alas, this is all speculation, but I do think that after eight years--and especially after 2012, when I fully expect the wingnut express to derail after nominating someone like Sarah Palin who will lose in a landslide--picking a winner could be a good deal more attractive to the Republicans. A Cristian (even worse!) GOP would be competitive nationally, while a Palinian GOP would only be able to compete in the Deep South, Alaska, and the Mormon Belt. So, while I'd rather have another Democrat elected to the Senate out of Florida, the GOP could do a whole lot worse than Charlie Crist.

Douthat on gay marriage/abortion

Ross Douthat makes a plausible argument to me about why the Obama Administration has not made much progress yet on gay issues:
On a national level, the issue still cuts against liberalism — but less so with every passing day. By pushing gay-rights debates off until later in his presidency, Obama is almost certainly making them easier to win.

I agree with this, and I am suprised that Andrew Sullivan--who frequently and correctly notes that Obama believes in the long game, the long-term strategy--is expecting everything to be done now. I do think that Obama should have ended Don't Ask, Don't Tell during the Honeymoon Phase, though I suspect that the delay has had more to do with placating the military establishment than with public opinion, which overwhelmingly supports the move.

I had something of a problem with this, though:
Thus gay marriage opponents’ persistent disadvantage. They can argue from tradition, custom and Christianity — as Obama himself does, albeit with dubious sincerity, to explain why he backs civil unions but not full-fledged marriage. They can note the perils of formally severing the link between marriage and childbearing in a society where far too many children are born outside of wedlock as it is. But supporters of gay marriage are the only ones making an argument from personal liberty — the freedom to marry, the right to marry — and that has made all the difference.

I'll skip the arguments equal justice for everyone, separation of church and state, and the hollowness of the traditional arguments against gay marriage. I've made them all before. Here's my question: is Ross making an argument against adoption here? I know he's strongly pro-life, and presumably he agrees with the presumably believes that women shouldn't procure abortions, but rather they should put their children up for adoption instead. Adoption, though, seems a way of separating the link between marriage and childbearing, both for the donors and the recipients.

Now, obviously, there is a coherent argument to be made here. One can say that adoption is superior to abortion, but inferior to a child staying in a male-female household. Fair enough. I don't even disagree with that, but this is the reason why Douthat's social system doesn't really work: people are going to have sex, and they're mostly not going to want to have 13 kids. (Not that there's anything wrong with big families, but they're not in vogue at the moment.) This means that there are going to be some abortions and some adoptions, naturally. Douthat would prefer more adoptions, presumably. But his argument doesn't really cut to the quick of the case for gay marriage--his argument doesn't address gay adoption, for example. Gay people aren't going to contribute to the numbers of children being born out of wedlock, they're going to detract from the children waiting to be adopted, which is otherwise cherished by Douthat. The column doesn't even address the arguments for gay marriage--I believe he is opposed, but he doesn't really give those of us who disagree much to think about. Plus, he doesn't address the sterile couples argument--in this case, childbearing isn't the mitigating factor. Why is that? I don't know if Ross is holding back here, but his argument here is sort of a weak punch. Douthat's columns so far have shown some insight and have had some interesting ideas in them, but I don't think he's quite grown into his columnist role yet. He does show some great promise, though.

The Man, The Myth, The Bio

East Bay, California, United States
Problem: I have lots of opinions on politics and culture that I need to vent. If I do not do this I will wind up muttering to myself, and that's only like one or two steps away from being a hobo. Solution: I write two blogs. A political blog that has some evident sympathies (pro-Obama, mostly liberal though I dissent on some issues, like guns and trade) and a culture blog that does, well, cultural essays in a more long-form manner. My particular thing is taking overrated things (movies, mostly, but other things too) down a peg and putting underrated things up a peg. I'm sort of the court of last resort, and I tend to focus on more obscure cultural phenomena.