Wednesday, April 14, 2010

Health care brown shoots

Josh Marshall is worried about a dip in health care's poll numbers. He doesn't posit an explanation, but it seems simple to me: over the past few weeks, Republicans and the media hyped up the decisions by several companies to possibly cut benefits after HCR ended senior prescription drug subsidies. The Democrats, to my observation, had hardly anything to say on the matter. Of course, these cuts are eminently defensible, as they were a sort of double-counting giveaway left over from Bush's Medicare bill, but nobody seemed to figure an explanation was warranted. I'd give half the Democratic majority for a competent press shop, I swear to you.

The way I see it, approval for this bill is going to be won on the basis of headlines. If there are lots of headlines about new consumer protections, coverage going up, new community health centers being built, etc., then people are going to think the venture is a good idea. If there are lots of stories about benefit cuts and the like, the opposite will occur. Democrats obviously think the former will outweigh the latter in time, and I do suppose it will. But in the here and now, this pretty much explains it. Of course, I'd feel a lot better if the Dems had someone manning the press shop that was actually good at getting messages into media coverage like Howard Wolfson, instead of Robert Gibbs.

By the way, I'm not ever sure if Gingrich is telling the truth or bullshitting, and it's especially unclear here. That he thinks that this polling dip is due to the public finding out more about the bill is pretty hard to believe. The round of coverage after the bill passed that focused on the benefits of the bill, and the polling went up. Then there was coverage of these write-offs, and the polling went down. The next round might well be positive, and the polls will go up. Gingrich isn't much of a politician, but rather a great self-promoter. That he is becoming a more plausible presidential candidate by the day is...interesting.

Today in brutal takedowns

I don't know when it happened, but at some point Jon Chait became my favorite blogger. Here he is shredding Jonah Goldberg on epistemic closure with respect to climate change:
In Goldberg's view, liberals and the overwhelming majority of climate scientists, with their peer-reviewed studies, who live in a sealed information bubble. And it's the conservatives -- backed by a handful of scientific renegades, a lot of oil company-sponsored propaganda, and a stream of observations about how Winter in North America remains cold -- who are really open to all sorts of data and interpretation here. I suppose if you take it as a given that climate change skepticism is correct, then a huge majority of the scientific world and intellectual elite is living in a bubble, and the tiny band of Fox News-watching, Limbaugh-listening conservatives are the ones outside the bubble.
Couldn't have said it better myself.

Tuesday, April 13, 2010

The Worst Conservative Columnist Strikes Again

My liberal brethren might prefer Bill Kristol, but for me good old Dennis Prager is the worst right-wing columnist in the land. In my view, the man is sort of the final stage of evolution in conservative thought: not only does he have no new innovative ideas, not only does he not really have a grasp of the classic conservative ideas, but he barely even understands the dogmatic propaganda practiced by the gutter rightists of conservative talk radio. He is to William F. Buckley what Fred Durst is to Paul McCartney, the rigor mortis of something once interesting and vital. I suppose it's just part of the natural cycle of things, but just sad nonetheless.

Here's how he starts his newest column: "Reading the onslaught of angry denunciations of Burger King by mental health organizations and mainstream media reporters this past week reminded me of a characteristic of the Left not often commented on [sic]..." Now, there are a number of characteristics of the Left that aren't frequently commented upon. Many of them would be perfectly fair grist for criticism from the right. Perhaps we could have a column about the ascendancy of science on the left vs. the irritating vaccine truthism that undermines that claim? No, rather it's one of the most obvious and lazy stereotypes of liberals one can find: "a certain joylessness, even an antipathy to the little joys that contribute more than almost anything else to most people's ability to endure the difficulties of life." Of course, the common stereotype of a liberal is either a hippie or a stern sermonizer (likely a feminist) which goes all the way back to jokes about those damn annoying suffragettes who won't just go home and please their men. That view is never never a middle-class black man or a union plumber, or an urban-dwelling twentysomething just living a normal life, which I'd guess are more prevalent paradigms for liberals these days.

So, Prager is lazy. But the hilarious part is how he diagnoses this supposed flaw:
Leftism functions as a (secular) religion. Like medieval Christians who wore hair shirts and Puritans who thought dancing was sacrilegious, the Left, consciously or not, is uncomfortable with many of the joys -- with notable exceptions such as sex and drugs -- that people experience.
Of course liberalism proceeds naturally from Puritanism. Because that makes sense. It's uninspired right agitprop that isn't even that good: the attack on Christianity is wrong for this readership, and the standard conservative line is that the left are hedonists who say, "Hey, man, if it feels good, do it!" This is what happens when one never reads any books on political philosophy and just has their worldview created by half-heard broadcasts of El Rushbo and Hannity. Meet Karl Pilkington, conservative pundit.

But Prager's article includes the other fresh new topics:
  • Liberals are just too sensitive
  • Smoking is great! Liberals hate it.
  • Kids should be playing more violent school games
  • Women should just accept sexism. No biggie.
  • The left sometimes puts limits on conspicuous consumption, and this is totally an infringement of our basic freedoms, man!
Look, I'm not going to say that all these are completely wrong. Liberals can be oversensitive. It's true. But this usually springs from a desire to make other people feel comfortable and welcomed. Perhaps there is overkill in this direction, certainly. But I think it stems from a fundamentally noble impulse. What one sees from Prager here is hostility to the notion that people should be concerned about the feelings of others. Hostility to the notion that he should have his behavior restrained in any way, from driving a big car to hitting on coworkers, from using his own light bulbs to smoking in public, although he hedges enough that it seems that little of the examples he cites (or, more often, refuses to cite) pertain to him. He confuses legislation with social mores, and while the former are debatable on a policy level, it's his take on the latter that confuses me. It's this whacked-out half-bit notion of freedom that some conservatives possess who apparently don't have a clue about the intense pressures that all society places on individuals to fit in, which are largely not evil and can actually make life quite a bit less stressful. On the whole I favor letting people do what they want to do, but this notion that society should be some sort of free-for-all bothers me. Frankly, it's not just women who are uncomfortable with a Hustler centerfold staring them in the face at an auto shop--it's me too. What's important to note here is that Prager is not defending some sort of vision of a less intrusive and more mellow society. He is defending his own boorishness and his mania to do whatever he wants. If someone has a problem with it, well, that's their problem. If you can't handle it, too bad. It's interesting that this guy makes two separate points about o'erweaning gender sensitivity despite the fact that he's been married about four times. It's practically poignant in his case. And you just know that if Prager got his wish, and people just dropped their inhibitions and started acting in the brutal, no-holds-barred way that he evidently likes, he'd be the first one whining about people being rude to him in public. What's he even advocating? Who even wants this stuff?

One of the liberal quips of conservative thought is that you can replace "freedom" in conservative slogans with "privilege" and get the desired result. This is generally reductive. For Prager, it's practically an understatement. (White male) privilege is not orthogonal to what he's saying. It's at best at a 45 degree angle.

Granholm for SCOTUS

It's interesting that, despite not being in the earliest lists, Michigan Gov. Jennifer Granholm has evidently become a top contender for the new Supreme Court berth. It's interesting because I thought (and think) she's the most obvious choice for the job.

Why? Because the politics sort of work out, just as they did for Sotomayor. It's regrettable that personal narrative tends to dominate these affairs, but Granholm has a pretty good rags-to-riches story and is definitely a self-made person. She's a political figure, true, which opens up new attacks on whether she'll be a partisan justice (though I suppose the right will say that about anybody), but she's from a moderate/swing state and will therefore be tough to portray as a hard-core leftist, and there are advantages to being a political figure as well, such as media skills, for example. She's got lots of legal and governing experience, the latter of which has been sorely lacking since Sandra Day O'Connor left the bench. And she's only 51, which means she'd probably get a good 35-plus years on the Court, which is an important consideration.

Ultimately, though, Granholm's best asset would be leadership and people skills--must-haves for a successful politician, though evidently not common among justices. These could make her a consequential figure on the bench, a la Earl Warren, who was hardly the most brilliant legal mind nor the most eloquent speaker, but who was an extremely talented manager and people person and thus exercised great power on the bench. I'll confess to not knowing much about some of the short list contenders, but it strikes me that Diane Wood and Merrick Garland are perhaps a bit old to get the nod, and Janet Napolitano could have a bumpy ride when one considers her tenure as Homeland Security chief. I suspect it will be either Elena Kagan or Granholm getting the nod, with perhaps a slight advantage to the latter because the sales case is more straightforward. Also, Kagan might have problems with the left because of her record on civil liberties. Picking her might unleash some unsightly and unnecessary drama. Considering Obama team's lack of desire to court unnecessary drama (I believe he earned some sort of nickname to that effect?), Granholm stands out as the most obvious, qualified, and perhaps best pick.

So she's my prediction. Then again, my prediction record is spotty--I've guessed the outcomes of the past couple of elections right, but I have also guessed that Charlie Crist would be Obama's Republican successor in 2017. I suppose it's too soon to say, but that seems less likely than it did about a year ago.

Monday, April 12, 2010

No liberal Scalia!

Okay, so it's not the most popular meme anymore. But you do hear liberals wishing for such a thing from time to time. I think it is misguided. Oh, I understand from whence it comes, but Scalia has not really been an asset for conservatives on the court. They certainly like Scalia, but one never hears about Scalia winning over moderate and liberal members of the Court to a certain decision, or doing anything aside from issuing scathing dissents. I have read a number of books about the Supreme Court during Scalia's tenure, and by all accounts he's frequently driven away moderate votes (notably Sandra Day O'Connor) to conciliatory liberals like Bill Brennan (and, later, Stephen Breyer). These days Scalia is mostly in the majority thanks to Bush-era appointees shifting the Court to the right, but this has little to do with his persuasive abilities. I'd much rather have someone like Earl Warren or Bill Brennan added to the Court--in other words, someone with leadership skills and persuasive ability--over an (admittedly brilliant) sneerer and splutterer. In other words, I'm not the sort of liberal who got excited when liberals yelled and screamed about Bush and Iraq, I'm the sort of liberal who gets excited when Bush gets voted out and when the war actually ends. Results are key, not feel-good righteous indignation that does nothing.

I did have another thought in this vein recently. In retrospect, the Democrats' inability to properly exploit the Harriet Miers nomination was a big mistake. I think it's very hard to argue that, from a liberal perspective, Alito is preferable to a potential Miers judgeship. She wasn't exactly prepared for the job, but the Dems' desire to defeat a Bush nominee and win a tactical victory ended up doing no good at all, as Miers's lack of conservative indoctrination might well have led her to follow the path that your Tony Kennedys and Sandra Day O'Connors followed, which is to say, toward a moderate approach of interpreting the law. My view is and has always been that the job of Supreme Court justice is not as hard as it is made out to be, and that any smart, hardworking lawyer will probably wind up doing a good job at it after a time of learning and adjustment. Then again, considering the Dem leadership of the time, I suppose we should just be thankful they didn't botch it any worse.

Romneymentum!

Larison analyzes Romney's latest tortured spin on health care here. Basically, he's trying to take credit for his state's HCR while denouncing Obama's HCR, and seeks to lead the opposition to Obama's bill despite being thoroughly compromised at best. And this guy's the best the Republicans have got? He'll get torn apart in a debate with Obama on this issue.

It occurs to me that health care is an albatross for Romney, but it's not the only one.
  1. He's a bad candidate. After raising and spending more money than any other Republican in the race in 2008, he's now confused with John Edwards, despite their looking not too much alike. He hasn't made much of an impression and isn't a national figure. One must conclude that he lacks the sort of charisma usually associated with the presidency. Now, if we had a parliamentary system in this country, he'd probably be an acceptable candidate for prime minister. But we don't have that kind of system.

  2. He's the wrong sort of Republican candidate. In the post-Eisenhower period, GOP presidential nominees have tended to be more on the plainspoken side of things (as opposed to smooth-talking), have tended to be more utilitarian-looking instead of movie-star handsome, and have tended to be more "gut thinkers" than intellectuals. There are exceptions to this, I suppose, Reagan being an obvious one for the first two conditions and Bush 41 being a possible exception for the third. But there's a reason why there are so few "Kennedyesque" Republican candidates in recent memory, and basically it's because an antigovernment party will naturally gravitate toward antipoliticians, even if they are studied and insincere antipoliticians (like Bush 43). Romney is a politician, not an antipolitician. And I suspect his campaign will be a lot like McCain's was in 2008. I don't think he'll have a significant problem with evangelicals because of his religion, as they'll show up to vote after Fox News yells socialism enough times. But he'll have problems with exciting the base more broadly. He's not one of them, and they won't forget it.

  3. Tone-deafness. Much has been made of Obama's political jiu-jitsu. Basically, he is able to turn around his opponents' attacks on themselves by subtly baiting them and then acting as though the other side is the aggressor to garner sympathy. It's a classic but difficult political strategy--Nixon was a notable practitioner of it as well. But with Romney, Obama won't even have to put in the effort. If history is any guide, Romney will unleash an incredibly scathing campaign against Obama, perhaps for holding views Romney recently held as well. And, if history is any guide, it won't work. Romney is not an especially nimble politician, and has never really proven able to present himself as the solution to everyone's problems. His establishment air and patrician nature--which he can't attenuate a la Bush 43--are likely to make Obama a far more appealing option, even despite issues with Wall Street and the economy. What would Romney's message even be? Change? Easy enough to turn into a punchline for him. I can just see the ads with two friends talking about Romney, with one saying that he's pro-choice, pro-gay, pro-gun control, good on the environment and immigration reform, and the other guy saying that he heard the opposite, and then the first guy asks which one is running for president, with the announcer saying that that is a good question. He'd be easy enough for Obama to define.

  4. What would it mean? A Romney loss would basically be as pointless and unproductive as McCain's loss. He would be invariably faulted as being insufficiently conservative, and we'd get another four years of FNC-style mayhem that denies the political space for across-the-aisle deals to be made.
I've been saying for ages that Palin would be the 2012 nominee, because it just makes sense. I actually think it could be a good thing. There's no way she'd be elected*, and it would be difficult for the right to blame the loss retrospectively on insufficient conservatism. Such a loss could be followed by a David Cameron-style movement to a sensible right, though that might be a little optimistic.

* Keep in mind that Palin getting elected would require her to stow the crazy and put in insane amounts of hard, grinding work for about 22 months. She hasn't even been on the national stage for 22 months and look what's happened already.

Thursday, April 8, 2010

A post on she who must not be named

I said I'd never post on her again, but this post from OpenLeft is cropping up on the internets:
If Sarah Palin runs for President in 2012, I have a difficult time imagining someone else winning the Republican nomination. While this is pretty good news for Democrats, as Palin polls worse against Obama than almost any other Republican (see also PPP polling), it is also pretty scary. A continually weak economy--which is very possible--could actually make her President less than three years from now.
Huckabee is the big variable here. I don't think he'll run, but if he doesn't rule himself out early Palin might not get in. Her career over the past two years shows a politician who, when confronted with a choice between putting in difficult, tough work and reaping easy gains, chooses the latter every time. If Huck bows out and his support mostly goes to Sarah, and the polls have her up by 10% or so, my guess is that she'll get in. If, on the other hand, she's neck and neck with Romney, she won't. Palin sees herself in elevated terms and would likely want to avoid the demeaning chores of the two-year job of being a presidential candidate, but she would get in if she thought it was a gimme and she could just do big rallies every once in a while. Of course, she might get in even if it doesn't seem like a sure thing, but it also seems entirely possible that her campaign might turn out the same as another candidate who hoped to coast on media skills, celebrity and laurels, who wrote off so many contests and just hoped that inevitability would carry him across the finish line. There are a number of similarities between Palin and Rudy Giuliani. What a mind-bender that ticket would be.

I have to say that I'm not terribly worried about Palin actually becoming president. Sure, a weak economy is a weak economy, but I don't think there's much of a reason to think she'll be a competent candidate. Part of the reason a lot of people started taking Obama seriously because he ran a disciplined, professional campaigned that was staffed with talented people. Obama, in other words, proved himself to be a good manager and an excellent judge of character and ability as a candidate, which are strengths that translated into a successful presidency. Palin has proven herself to be a slouch in all these respects, raiding the dregs of the McCain campaign for staff (e.g. Randy Schunemann), and her record as a manager is sketchy at best. Obama proved himself to be a competitor who thrived on pressure, not to mention an effective closer. Palin proved herself to be a basketcase under pressure. This whole thing about the Tea Parties strikes me as equivalent to the 70s-era New Left--an enthusiasm rather than a true movement. Perhaps appealing to nation wanting to blow off steam about a lousy economy, but doomed as soon as it has to put out a realistic agenda. And, of course, Nixon wasn't really running on a rock-solid economy in 1972.

Or so I hope. But I continue to think that a Palin candidacy would be every bit as bad for the right as George McGovern was for the left. Both were/are extremely out of their depth on that platform, and when one considers that Palin can basically only do one thing, and that it's continually being proven that that one thing isn't really that popular with voters, I'm not that gloomy at this point. Actually, it could be great--the sort of thing that could break the back of the angry noise machine if she loses in a landslide. I think you'll start to see the White House making subtle barbs at Palin starting after the midterm elections, with other Democrats making more obvious swipes at her, in hopes that there will be a Clinton effect in which attacks from the outside make Republicans rally around Palin.

Well, I suppose he would know a little something about that

Reading anything by Karl Rove is a strange experience. Virtually every accusation he lobs at his opponents is not only untrue, but it's almost perfectly true of himself. Here's one good example from the Wall Street Journal:

Obama Has Overpromised and Underdelivered

In the real world, the Obama/Pelosi/Reid triumvirate has produced the following accomplishments so far:
  • Passing the stimulus bill, which has cushioned the blow from the recession
  • Passed the Lily Ledbetter Act
  • Passed student loan reform
  • Passed health care reform
  • Passed sweeping regulation of the credit card industry, and is likely to reregulate Wall Street
  • Passed new regulations on the tobacco industry
  • Has signed a new treaty to reduce the prevalence of nuclear arms
Admittedly, Obama hasn't been nearly good enough on security matters, often taking Republican-lite stands on these matters (though the end of torture, of course, removes the most objectionable of Bush-era practices). He's unfortunately (though understandably) reversed himself on recognizing the Armenian genocide. Immigration reform is very unlikely to happen, except for as part of a strategy to make the right look awful (possibly in conjunction with a repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell). And Obama's economic team vastly misread the depth of our economic problems at the outset of their term and foolishly didn't try to put a safety cushion in the stimulus in case the problems were worse than they seemed. But the truth is that Obama has generally produced about at the level at which he promised.

Now, the Bush White House was a different story. Coming off an election in 2004 that was supposed to settle a permanent Republican majority--in itself a dubious goal, as states with protracted one-party rule tend to be corrupt, dysfunctional and ruling parties tend to do whatever will keep them in power--the GOP failed catastrophically to deliver the goods, tossing away senior support with an abandoned attempt to privatize Social Security and losing Hispanic support by botching the immigration reform debate. In neither case could the Republicans deliver what they promised, in the first case because few people actually wanted to mess with Social Security, and the latter because immigration is anathema to conservatives. And, of course, there's Bush's foreign policy adventures that were billed as a way to turn the Middle East into a democratic oasis.

In fact, I'd go even bigger than this. Movement conservatism has for decades overpromised its followers on things like abortion, the scope of government, the Clinton impeachment, and so on. While many former right-wingers have been disgruntled at the results of all this and have moved to the center, the remaining core is actually completely uninterested in the results of the enterprise. They must be, since they apparently read columns by Karl Rove.

Friday, April 2, 2010

A Clinton Healthcare Counterfactual

Kevin Drum ponders Bruce Bartlett's counterfactual that Clinton would have governed more conservatively than Obama here.

I don't know the answer to this, but I suspect that Bartlett is correct in general. I don't think he's specifically right about health care, which always seemed to be the issue she cared about most, but I don't really think you would have seen a lot of the successes that Obama has had under Clinton. I highly doubt that, for example, Clinton would have made any of the same moves Obama has to tamp down the drug war. Coming of age politically when she did, I doubt she would have touched that. I doubt even more that Clinton would have pursued an ambitious arms control treaty as Obama has. As for foreign policy, I think Obama's approach has generally yielded good results, perhaps better than a Clinton Administration would have, though one can never be sure. A Clinton Administration would undoubtedly have pursued different priorities--a stronger emphasis on women's rights around the world, probably less of an emphasis on Israel-Palestine considering Bill Clinton's disappointment in 2000, and in general probably the same broad contours with respect to Iraq and Af-Pak. That might have been good! Or not. Honestly, Obama hasn't really done too many out-of-the-mainstream things on foreign policy, and it's easy to imagine Clinton ordering many of the same actions.

There have been some disappointments for me over the past year or so, and a few blunders as well. But I still think the right guy won, and his record has been such that I'm happy with his performance so far--and the ways in which I'm unhappy with it (mostly security and civil liberties stuff) certainly weren't going to be any better with Clinton or McCain in command.

Thursday, April 1, 2010

Why not Blanche?

Chait thinks liberals should leave Blanche Lincoln alone:
I don't quite get why Lincoln is facing a primary challenger at all. I understand the general principle of fielding primary challengers to force Democrats to accept some political risk for the sake of enacting progressive policies. I just don't get why Lincoln is the target. I'm not an enormous fan of hers -- I'm fairly proud of my 2006 column ridiculing her incoherent views on fiscal policy -- but she does indeed hail from a very conservative state.
I'm not impervious to this logic. If Lincoln's the best candidate who can win, then I say leave her alone. But Chait misses an important fact: she's highly unlikely to win. Nate Silver gives her a 4% chance against the most likely Republican candidate, John Boozman. If Lincoln were tied or even a modest underdog against Boozman, he'd be right. But she's almost a certain loser, and she evidently intends to lose in a dispiriting fit of triangulation. Which means we're most likely in a Lion In Winter-style situation, as in this (frequently misquoted) part from the play/film (courtesy of IMDB):
Prince Richard: [the sons - in the dungeon - think they hear Henry approach] He's here. He'll get no satisfaction out of me. He isn't going to see me beg.
Prince Geoffrey: My you chivalric fool... as if the way one fell down mattered.
Prince Richard: When the fall is all there is, it matters.
I really don't see any downside to trying to dump Lincoln. She did vote for health care reform, this is true. But she has even less of a chance of winning than Mark Halter, and Halter has more of a chance of being a wild card--younger, more passionate, more principled, and something resembling a real Democrat--instead of a Clintonian anachronism like Blanche. It's going to be a strange new world next Congress, with the most obvious avatars of Clintonism--namely Bayh and Lincoln--out of the picture. It will be interesting. But Halter is, to my mind, a smart choice for progressives.

A smarter choice, in any event, than dumping Arlen Specter, which seems unlikely to happen at this point. I like Joe Sestak just fine, but he seems to have miscalculated in taking on this contest instead of running for governor, which would have suited him better. Specter's record this Congress has given progressives little to complain about, and Sestak's emails have become less compelling over the past few months, mostly focusing on Specter's previous Republicanism that seems ages old at this point. Plus, the old guy's been doing better in the polls in the past few months. I have no particular love for Specter and would prefer Sestak to win it, all things being equal, but then again they never are. At the very least, his continued presence in the Senate will really irritate the Erick Ericksons of the world for a few more years.

The Man, The Myth, The Bio

East Bay, California, United States
Problem: I have lots of opinions on politics and culture that I need to vent. If I do not do this I will wind up muttering to myself, and that's only like one or two steps away from being a hobo. Solution: I write two blogs. A political blog that has some evident sympathies (pro-Obama, mostly liberal though I dissent on some issues, like guns and trade) and a culture blog that does, well, cultural essays in a more long-form manner. My particular thing is taking overrated things (movies, mostly, but other things too) down a peg and putting underrated things up a peg. I'm sort of the court of last resort, and I tend to focus on more obscure cultural phenomena.