Thursday, April 22, 2010

Inhofe is right???????? About anything??

It appears so:
Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.) said that his fellow GOP senators who voted to pass the $700 billion bailout program in the fall or 2008 run a political risk now, when the Senate has moved onto financial reform legislation.

"Republicans have a problem on this," Inhofe said during an appearance on WLS radio in Chicago. "As you know, I was leading the opposition in October of '08 to the $700 billion bailout. And the Republicans, most of them caved in, and all the Democrats did."

"And so I was cautioning them on this: don't try to paint this so much as the Wall Street bailout as it is, whatever they come up with, because we are vulnerable," Inhofe explained of that bailout. "I'm not personally, because I opposed it, but most of -- almost all the Republicans went along with it."
It's pretty insane that Inhofe is the one who is acting like the Republican voice of reason here. That says a lot in and of itself. What's more amazing is that he's actually putting a pin to the epistemic closure bubble that the right has meticulously constructed around this issue. He's correct that the bulk of the GOP caucus wound up supporting TARP back in the day, but the new Republican narrative is that the GOP is the Enemy of the Bailouts, that they were never necessary and that Bush Obama wasted taxpayer dollars on them, etc.

My guess is that the right will ignore Inhofe easily enough, despite the fact that the usually insane old buzzard has made an excellent point.

Immigration or climate change?

I'm not so sure I like what Dems are choosing here.

Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Am I wrong?

Stuff like this makes me think that Obama might pick Diane Wood as a SCOTUS nominee, despite her age. But I'm going to stick with my prediction for the time being.

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

If only...

Reading this great op-ed in Ha'aretz just makes me wish for a day when we can actually have a conversation about Israel like this in our country.

No repeal

Jon Chait's piece about the right's HCR repeal fantasy is pretty good, but perhaps overthinking things. The simple truth is that the fight to repeal reform (in a world where Republicans were actually in a position to do it) would be just as messy as the fight to enact it was. The right would have to do battle with the combined forces of PhRMA, the AMA, the AARP, labor, etc. Considering the flat-out disbelief that most Republicans (namely Newt Gingrich) displayed at the prospects of the Democrats putting it all on the line for HCR, I don't expect the GOP to mirror the Democrats' drive on this issue. Enacting HCR only happened because it was a decades-old dream of the left. The same cannot be said of repeal.

Additionally, it's worth nothing that the GOP hasn't had the stomach for a really tough ideological fight since Gingrich's government shutdown. Welfare reform was, of course, bipartisan, as were No Child Left Behind and Medicare Part D, though the latter is perhaps the definitive example of where bipartisanship produces a worse product than would otherwise be reached. In any event, the Bush Administration's domestic policy was one of minimal risk, one that would take 1/4 of a loaf from the Democrats when possible and back off once the going got tough, as in immigration reform and privatization of Social Security. Of course, this was because Bush had other priorities that he was more interested in pursuing, but I tend to think that the rest of the GOP will rage about repeal for some months, not really bother too much about health care if they do win the House, and then complain about how the Democrats are being difficult if their followers ask them any questions about the whole thing. It's just SOP for them at this point.

Monday, April 19, 2010

Financial reform opposition is weak tea

Dave Weigel discusses Mitch McConnell's anti-reg gambit here. Here's the conclusion: "The success of McConnell's push depends, I think, on how often Republicans say this without getting follow-up questions. So far they've been getting a lot of follow-ups -- the reliance on this talking point is just so obvious."

I think McConnell's problem here, as opposed to health care reform, is that he's trying to create a new connection instead of emphasizing an existing one. A lot of people in this country want to fundamentally reform health care, but many of them worry about the implications of an increased government role in health care, perhaps after hearing some horror stories about rationing and what not. So, while something like "death panels" can easily be scoffed at by most everyone, it taps an anxiety that exists and can therefore be somewhat subtly effective. (Admittedly the death panels claim specifically was Sarah Palin's work, but all the stuff about rationing was pretty widespread among Republicans.)

Most people, I think, have absorbed that Wall Street melted down because people were doing crazy things and regulators were either looking the other way or didn't have the tools to deal with it. McConnell's strategy is to try to lump in regulatory reform with unpopular bailouts, only there's an extra step he'll have to make there that didn't have to be made to make people anxious about HCR. People might have some anxieties about Wall Street reform, but I don't think the fear of it leading to more bailouts is terribly intuitive. I don't really think McConnell has a winning hand here, but I think the Luntzian groupthink will prove more damaging than would otherwise be the case.

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Perhaps I spoke too soon?

Carly Fiorina is having some issues. If she has to quit, I wonder how the Senate race here will shake out. The California GOP is extremely conservative, and if it becomes the already-deflating moderatish Tom Campbell vs. real conservative Chuck DeVore, I think DeVore will experience a big surge. Could be another Crist/Rubio type of thing.

California status update

How is the Golden State looking politically these days? Well, evidently the race to replace Barbara Boxer is getting closer, unbelievably, with Carly Fiorina pulling closer to Tom Campbell. I guess the notion that Campbell is moderate (which isn't true, though he is neither insane nor intransigent) is leading to a Fiorina surge.

My take is that Campbell is the only moderately threatening person in this race to Barbara Boxer, even though I wouldn't give Campbell more than 4:1 odds of actually winning. He is generally pretty libertarian on social and economic issues, which is not a terrible fit for a state that has a hidden streak of fiscal conservatism. In normal times he wouldn't have a chance, but with the economy being worse in California than the rest of the country a Scott Brown moment isn't completely impossible. Then again, Boxer isn't as dumb as Martha Coakley, Campbell isn't as charismatic as Scott Brown, etc., but it's not impossible if all the planets were to align in such a way...

Fiorina, however, is a joke. The Demon Sheep ad that everyone knows is pretty much indicative of her entire career in politics and business. I used to live right next to HP HQ, so I know quite well how she nearly drove her company into the ground back in the day. Her stint flacking for John McCain in 2008 was nearly as bad. She's already been something of a trainwreck as a candidate and would not pose a serious challenge to Boxer. Unlike Campbell, she's running as a traditional, Reagan style fiscal and social conservative to appeal to the hard-right GOP base in the state (for whom time stopped in 1989, more or less). That's not going to play in a state where 3/4 of the public (including almost half of Republicans) self-identify as pro-choice. And option #3, Chuck DeVore, is a DeMintite who mostly resembles the hapless losers the GOP runs against Dianne Feinstein every time she's up when they don't expect a serious contest.

Campbell is the most interesting and unorthodox of the Republicans running for the nomination, and he's definitely the most talented and intelligent. Ultimately, though, Campbell lives in the real world instead of the Supply-Side Neocon Land that most Republicans occupy, which has prompted him to occasionally acknowledge that Israel has made some errors in judgment over the past few years, and to sometimes cut budget deals with Democrats in the legislature. My sense is that conservatives don't much care for Carly, but that Campbell is rapidly becoming an unacceptable choice for Republicans (in other words, he's getting Scozzafavaed). He's also associated with Arnold Schwarzenegger and his within-the-margin-of-error approval ratings, which can't help.

As for the governor's race, I'm intrigued that Meg Whitman has taken a small lead over Jerry Brown. I've seen her ads on TV, and they've not been terrible. But I do wonder if she'll be able to pull it off. I'm not a huge fan of Brown, and I would consider voting for Whitman if she were to propose fixing the proposition process and the 2/3 budget vote requirement. Of course she won't do these things, but ultimately voting for Meg Whitman or Arnold Schwarzenegger for governor is sort of like voting for an independent candidate for president. These people have no real base--CA Republicans hate Schwarzenegger because he's moderate--so they can't ever really get anything done. I'm not that wild about California Democrats (with some exceptions), but it sure makes more sense to vote for people who might have the means to accomplish something.

The irony of all this might be that Whitman could be saved by heavy voting by downballot Republican voters who want the Republicans to retake Congress.

Here's a shocker

Scott Brown is against regulatory reform. And not too convincingly.

Look, I get that the guy isn't a reflexive right-winger. He's moderate on some stuff and I think he really doesn't want to be the next Michele Bachmann. But this guy built his campaign on soliciting huge donations from Wall Street titans after Citizens United. Acting as though he's a gettable vote here is silly--he even campaigned against the issue, which was missed opportunity 4,598 in Martha Coakley's campaign, but I digress.

On the other hand, I suspect Brown will fully support whoever gets the next nomination to the Supreme Court. Not that it'll matter much, as these things never get filibustered, but it's the sort of follow-a-conservative-thing-with-a-moderate-one that Brown has been doing for the past few months. I want to know how the guy plays something like energy reform.

Another drawback to Elena Kagan

Lexington has one:
Another possible objection, for Democrats, is that she would have to recuse herself from all cases in which, as solicitor-general, she played a role. That could be a huge number of cases. Ed Whelan, a socially conservative court-watcher, supplies some historical context:

[L]et’s look to the last justice who was appointed to the Court from the position of Solicitor General, Thurgood Marshall.

Marshall served as Solicitor General from August 1965 to August 1967. He joined the Court on August 31, 1967. According to Lawrence S. Wrightsman’s The Psychology of the Supreme Court (p. 79), “Marshall recused himself from 98 of the 171 cases that were decided by the Supreme Court during the 1967-1968 term.” That’s 57% of the total. (Wrightsman states that “most of these were cases in which the federal government had been a party”; I suspect that all or nearly all of them were.)

One well-informed source tells me that the percentage of cases in which the United States takes part is much higher than in Marshall’s day and that in a recent term that figure approached 80%. My quick tally of the hearing lists for cases argued so far this term yields a figure of around 76%.

In other words, during Ms Kagan's first year, the court would have a 5-3 conservative-liberal split on most cases, instead of 5-4. That's something to think about.
Here's my question: if she's the most popular choice among conservatives--if she's best buds with Scalia and gets the endorsement of Bill Kristol--doesn't it make sense to keep her in reserve in case one of the more conservative justices retires? Then you'd be moving the court leftward overall in such an event.

The Man, The Myth, The Bio

East Bay, California, United States
Problem: I have lots of opinions on politics and culture that I need to vent. If I do not do this I will wind up muttering to myself, and that's only like one or two steps away from being a hobo. Solution: I write two blogs. A political blog that has some evident sympathies (pro-Obama, mostly liberal though I dissent on some issues, like guns and trade) and a culture blog that does, well, cultural essays in a more long-form manner. My particular thing is taking overrated things (movies, mostly, but other things too) down a peg and putting underrated things up a peg. I'm sort of the court of last resort, and I tend to focus on more obscure cultural phenomena.